McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Comparison - Dog breed selector: McNab Herding Dog or English Collie or Danish Broholmer Danish Mastiff? Find the right dog for you

"Find similarities and differences between McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer" Compare McNab and Rough Collie. Which is better: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?

Size and Weight Price and Availability Trainability and Intelligence Personality and Temperament Activity and Playfulness Adaptability and Independence Bite Characteristics Health and Lifespan Energy and Activity Diet and Weight Management Allergies and Grooming Good With As a Working Dog Reproducibility Recognition Show differences only

Name	McNab	Rough Collie	Broholmer
Origins	United States	Scotland	Denmark
All Dog Breeds By Country Of Origin
Group	Pastoral / Herding Dogs	Pastoral / Herding Dogs	Guard Dogs
Popularity Rank	398	40	235
Reviews	1	6	0
User Ratings

Other Names What other names do they have?	McNab Herding Dog McNab Sheepdog McNab Border Collie	English Collie Lassie Dog Long-Haired Collie Scottish Collie Collie	Danish Broholmer Danish Mastiff
Breed Type Which dog is purebred or crossbreed? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer breed type comparison:	Purebred	Purebred	Purebred

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Size and Weight Comparison

Size Which is bigger, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which is the smallest dog, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	Medium	Large	Large Giant
Weight Which is heavier, McNab or Rough Collie or Rough Collie? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer weight comparison:	Male: 35-65 lbs (16-30 kg), Female: 30-50 lbs (14-23 kg)	Male: 60-70 pounds (27-32 kg), Female: 53-65 pounds (24-29 kg)	Male: 110-150 pounds (50-68 kg), Female: 90-130 pounds (40-58 kg)
Average Weight Which dog has a smaller / higher average weight?	Male: 35-65 lbs (23 kg), Female: 30-50 lbs (18.5 kg)	Male: 67.5 pounds (30.5 kg), Female: 57.5 pounds (26 kg)	Male: 130 pounds (59 kg), Female: 110 pounds (49 kg)
Height Which is taller, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer height comparison:	Male: 18-25 inches (45-64 cm), Female: 16-21 inches (40-54 cm)	Male: 24–26 inch (60–66 cm), Female: 22–24 inch (55–61 cm)	Male: 29.5 inches (75 cm) Female: 27.5 inches (70 cm)
Average Height Which dog has a smaller / higher average height?	Male: 21.5 inches (54.5 cm), Female: 18.5 inches (47 cm)	Male: 25 inches (62.5 cm), Female: 23 inches (58.5 cm)	Male: 29.5 inches (75 cm) Female: 27.5 inches (70 cm)

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Price and Availability Comparison

Price Which is cheaper, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which is more expensive?	$300-$500	$400-$600	$1300-$1500
Availability Which is easier to get, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	Average: The McNab is a commonly available dog breed.	Very frequent: The Rough Collie is quite easy to get.	Average: The Broholmer is a commonly available dog breed.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Trainability and Intelligence Comparison

Intelligent Rank Which is the smarter dog? Which is best? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer intelligence:	Average: It takes patience to teach this breed any tricks or commands, but the effort is worth it. See more.	Very smart: Rough Collie is an excellent dog breed. See more.	Smart: The Broholmer dogs have great intelligence. See more.
Smartest Dog Breeds
Trainability McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer trainability comparison.	McNab dogs are quite easy to train. See more.	Rough Collie dogs are very easy to train. See more.	Broholmer dogs are quite easy to train. See more.
Least Obedient Dog Breeds		Dog Breeds That Easy To Train
Watchdog Ability Which is the better watchdog: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	McNab dogs are average watchdogs. See more.	Rough Collie dogs are one of the best watchdogs. See more.	Broholmer dogs are one of the best watchdogs. See more.
Guarding Behavior / Territorial Which is a better guard dog McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which dog is most likely to protect its owner? Which is the best dog to use for protection?	McNab dogs strongly protect their territory. See more.	Rough Collie dogs are extremely protective guard dogs. See more.	Broholmer dogs are extremely protective guard dogs. See more.
Guard Dog Breeds List

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Personality and Temperament Comparison

Temperament Which one has a better personality? Which is a better family dog, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer behavior/temperament comparison:	Protective Friendly Obedient Sociable Hard Working Mannered	Protective Intelligent Friendly Responsive Docile Obedient Loyal Gentle Social Elegant Hard working Herding	Protective Confident Friendly Calm
Sensitivity Level Which dog is more sensitive? What's the difference?	They are a little bit more sensitive than other dog breeds. See more.	Sensitive: Rough Collie dogs don't like an irregular daily routine, noisy household, and frequent guest visits. See more.	Broholmer dogs have an average emotional level and are not the most sensitive dog breed. See more.
Most Sensitive Dog Breeds		Less Sensitive Dog Breeds
Affection Level Which is the more affectionate dog breed: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	High: McNab dogs are genuinely loyal, soft and gentle, loving, and affectionate dogs toward their handlers. See more.	High: Rough Collie dogs are genuinely loyal, soft and gentle, loving, and affectionate dogs toward their handlers. See more.	Average to High: Broholmer dogs are highly affectionate dogs. See more.
Most Affectionate Dog Breeds
Social Needs McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer social needs comparison:	McNab dogs need for social interaction is average. See more.	Rough Collie dogs need a lot of social interaction. See more.	Broholmer dogs need for social interaction is average. See more.
Impulse to Wander or Roam Which dog has a greater roaming instinct?	McNab dogs have average wanderlust potential. See more.	Rough Collie dogs are not the biggest explorers. See more.	Broholmer dogs tend to escape less than other breeds. See more.
Prey Drive Which dog has a higher prey drive? Which can be better for hunting?	McNab dogs have an average prey drive, which means that they don't have a high impulse to chase and catch something like a cat or any other small aminals, but it might happen. See more.	Rough Collie dogs have a higher impulse to chase and catch something than other dog breeds. See more.	Broholmer dogs have low to an average impulse to chase and catch something like a cat or any other small aminals. See more.
Dog Breeds With Low Prey Drive		Dog Breeds With High Prey Drive

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Activity and Playfulness Comparison

Playfulness McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer playfulness comparison:	Average: McNabs, like any other dog breed, like playing. See more.	The Rough Collie is a playful breed. See more.	Average: Broholmers, like any other dog breed, like playing. See more.
Most Playful Dog Breeds
Barking Which dog barks more/less: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	Low to Average: The McNab rarely barks. See more.	Low to Average: The Rough Collie rarely barks. See more.	Average to High: The Broholmer is a vocal breed. See more.
Quiet Dog Breeds That Don't Bark		Dog Breeds That Bark The Most
Apartment Friendly Which dog is more apartment friendly McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	It is not the best choice if you want to keep them indoors, however, with careful exercise and several walks a day, they will tolerate the indoor environment, so it is possible to keep McNab indoors.	It is not the best choice if you want to keep them indoors, however, with careful exercise and several walks a day, they will tolerate the indoor environment, so it is possible to keep Rough Collie indoors.	It is not the best choice if you want to keep them indoors, however, with careful exercise and several walks a day, they will tolerate the indoor environment, so it is possible to keep Broholmer indoors.
The Worst Dog Breeds for Apartment Living		Apartment Friendly Dogs List

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Adaptability and Independence Comparison

Adaptability Which dog has a higher adaptability potential? Which is the better dog?	Average: McNab dogs adapt to lifestyle changes and different living environments quite okay usually.	Rough Collie dogs adapt well to lifestyle changes and different living environments.	Broholmer dogs adapt well to lifestyle changes and different living environments.
Tolerates Being Left Alone Which dog can be left alone: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	Just like every puppy, they are prone to panic, cry, bark, whine when they left alone by their owner.	Rough Collie dogs tend to have separation anxiety when their owners left them alone at home because they bond very closely with them.	Just like every puppy, they are prone to panic, cry, bark, whine when they left alone by their owner.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Bite Characteristics Comparison

Bite Force PSI Which bite is stronger: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	Between 200 and 400 PSI ⏺ McNab bite force: Ordinary.	Between 200 and 400 PSI ⏺ Rough Collie bite force: Ordinary.	Above 400 PSI 🔼 Broholmer bite force: The Strongest.
Dog Breeds With The Lowest Bite Force		Dog Breeds With the Strongest Bite Force
Biting Potential Which breed of dog is most likely to bite? Biting potential comparison:	Low 🔽 The McNab has a low chance of biting somebody.	Low 🔽 The Rough Collie has a low chance of biting somebody.	Low 🔽 The Broholmer has a low chance of biting somebody.
Mouthiness Which is the better dog? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer mouthiness comparison:	McNab dogs have an average tendency to nip, chew, playbite, or herd people. See more.	Rough Collie dogs have an average tendency to nip, chew, playbite, or herd people. See more.	Broholmer dogs have an average tendency to nip, chew, playbite, or herd people. See more.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Health and Lifespan Comparison

Health Issues McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer health comparison. Which is the healthier: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	The McNab is a healthy breed, but there are certain health issues that you should check with your vet regularly.	The Rough Collie is a healthy breed, but there are certain health issues that you should check with your vet regularly.	Broholmers are commonly healthy dogs.
Healthiest Dog Breeds
Health Problems Which one has more or less genetic/health problems: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer? What are the allergies, genetic diseases and concerns for them? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer health problems comparison:	Primary Lens Luxation	Hip Dysplasia Progressive retinal atrophy (PRA) Drug Sensitivity Collie Eye Anomaly Gray Collie Syndrome	Cataracts Hip Dysplasia Progressive retinal atrophy (PRA) Entropion Ectropion Elbow Dysplasia
Veterinarian Visits Which one may need more or less veterinary visits?	Average The McNab should have a complete physical check-up at least once per year.	Average The Rough Collie should have a complete physical check-up at least once per year.	Rare The Broholmer should have a complete physical check-up at least every 12-18 months (but preferably once per year).
Longest Living Dog Breeds
Life Expectancy McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer lifespan comparison. How long do McNab, Rough Collie and Broholmer breeds live? Which one has a longer lifespan/life expectancy?	13-15 years The average lifespan of McNab: 14 years	14-16 years The average lifespan of Rough Collie: 15 years	10-12 years The average lifespan of Broholmer: 11 years
Calculate dog years to human years by breed here
Weather and Climate Which dog is best for hot or cold weather: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	Tolerates warm and cold weather Dogs that tolerate hot and cold weather are typically those that have a double coat of fur. See more.	Prefers average to cold weather conditions The Rough Collie can adapt to well to cold weather conditions, some dogs even can be a good mountain dog. See more.	Prefers average to cold weather conditions The Broholmer can adapt to well to cold weather conditions, some dogs even can be a good mountain dog. See more.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Energy and Activity Comparison

Energy Level Who has more energy a McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer energy level comparison:	McNab dogs have a higher energy level than other dog breeds.	Rough Collie dogs have an average energy level, so if you live a semi-active life, this breed can be a good choice for you.	Broholmer dogs have an average energy level, so if you live a semi-active life, this breed can be a good choice for you.
Low-Energy Dog Breeds		High-Energy Dog Breeds
Activity Requirement / Exercise Need McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer exercise need comparison. Which dog needs more activity? Which dog needs the most exercise: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which dog needs the most walking? Which dog is the laziest?	McNab dogs need quite a lot of exercise.	Rough Collie dogs need quite a lot of exercise.	Broholmer dogs need quite a lot of exercise.
Sleeping Need Which one sleeps the least/most: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	McNab dogs are quite energetic dogs and they don't spend too much time with sleeping.	Rough Collie dogs sleep 12-14 hours a day as an average dog and they're not considered a lazy breed.	Broholmer dogs sleep 12-14 hours a day as an average dog and they're not considered a lazy breed.
Dog Breeds That Sleep A Lot

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Diet and Weight Management Comparison

Average daily food consumption Which dog eats more: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	1.5 to 2 cups of high-quality dry food a day, divided into two or three meals.	2 to 3 cups of high-quality dry food a day, divided into two meals.	5 to 6 cups of high-quality dry food a day, divided into two meals.
Dog Breeds That Eat A Lot
Weight Gain Potential / Prone to Obesity Which dog breed is more prone to obesity? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer weight gain potential comparison:	Average: The McNab has an average risk for obesity. See more.	Average: The Rough Collie has an average risk for obesity. See more.	Average to High: If you don't pay attention to the Broholmer's weight, he can easily gain weight. See more.
Dog Breeds Prone To Obesity

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Allergies and Grooming Comparison

Coat / Hair Types What type of coat/fur do they have? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer coat comparison:	Smooth	Rough Soft Thick Straight Harsh Furry	Rough Smooth
Colors What are the original McNab, Rough Collie and Broholmer color?	Black White Brown Tricolor	White Sable Merle Black & White & Tan Blue & Merle Blue & Merle & White Sable & White White & Merle	Red Yellow Golden
Grooming Which dog is easy to maintain, McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer grooming comparison:	Average: The McNab requires average grooming effort. See more.	Professional: This breed needs a lot of work to keep in good condition. See more.	Easy to groom: The Broholmer doesn't require a lot of grooming. See more.
Low-Maintenance Dog Breeds		High-Maintenance Dog Breeds
Shedding Level Who sheds more McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? McNab or Rough Collie or {name3 shedding:	McNab dogs shed moderately. See more.	Rough Collie dogs are heavy shedders. See more.	Broholmer dogs shed moderately. See more.
Low-Shedding Dog Breeds		Dog Breeds That Shed The Most
Bath Time / Bathing Frequency Which dog should be bathed more: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	4-6 weeks Average. Experts recommended at least every 4-6 weeks for this family pup. See more.	3-4 weeks More often than average. These dog coats tend to be longer, softer, and oilier than short-haired breeds. See more.	4-6 weeks Average. Experts recommended at least every 4-6 weeks for this family pup. See more.
Hypoallergenic McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer hypoallergenic comparison. Which dog is hypoallergenic or not?	No See more.	No See more.	No See more.
Hypoallergenic Dog Breeds
Stinkiness Which dog breed smells the least? Which dog smells the most? Which is best, McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	Medium ⏺ The McNab has an average chance of bad smell.	Medium ⏺ The Rough Collie has an average chance of bad smell.	Medium ⏺ The Broholmer has an average chance of bad smell.
Drooling Tendency Which dog drools the most? Which dog drools the least?	The McNab is a perfect example of a very low drooling tendency. See more.	The Rough Collie is a perfect example of a very low drooling tendency. See more.	The Broholmer is a big drooler, so if you're disgusted by slobber spots on your clothes, you should choose a dog from another breed. See more.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Good With Comparison

Pet Friendly Which dog breeds get along well with other animals/pets?	McNab dogs are generally with other pets.	Rough Collie dogs are one of the friendliest dog breeds.	Broholmer dogs usually don’t get on well with other pets.
Stranger Friendly Which dog is more stranger friendly McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which dog is more friendly?	McNab dogs are average friendly towards strangers.	Rough Collie dogs are stranger-friendly dogs.	Broholmer dogs are not the most stranger-friendly dogs.
Dog Breeds That Are Aloof With Strangers		Dog Breeds That Are Friendly To Strangers
Child Friendly Which dog is more child/kid friendly McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	McNab dogs are kid-friendly dogs.	Rough Collie dogs are very kid-friendly dogs.	Broholmer dogs are kid-friendly dogs.
Kid-Friendly Dog Breeds
Cat Friendly Which dog is more cat friendly McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	McNab dogs are average friendly towards cats.	Rough Collie dogs are very cat-friendly dogs.	Broholmer dogs are not the most cat-friendly dogs.
Dog Breeds That Get Along Well With Cats
Dog Friendly Which dog is more dog friendly McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer?	McNab dogs are average friendly towards other dogs.	Rough Collie dogs are dog-friendly dogs.	Broholmer dogs are average friendly towards other dogs.
Good For First Time Owners Which dog is good for the first-time owners: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	Yes McNab dogs are good for novice owners, due to their easy-going personality.	Yes Rough Collie dogs are good for novice owners, due to their easy-going personality.	Yes Broholmer dogs are good for novice owners, due to their easy-going personality.
Office Friendly Which one fits better in the office?	No McNab is not the best dog breed for office environment.	No Rough Collie is not the best dog breed for office environment.	No Broholmer is not the best dog breed for office environment.
Senior Citizens Friendly Which dog is good for elderly people?	McNabs are usually recommended for elderly people.	Rough Collies are one of the best breeds for elderly people.	Broholmers are usually recommended for elderly people.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer As a Working Dog Comparison

Service Dog Which one could be a service dog?	Not really This breed generally not used as a service dog. See more.	Yes This breed makes good as a service dog. See more.	Not really This breed generally not used as a service dog. See more.
Most Popular Service Dog Breeds
Therapy Dog Which one could be a therapy dog: McNab or Rough Collie or Broholmer? Which is better for autism?	Not really This breed is generally not used as a therapy dog. See more.	Yes This breed makes a perfect therapy dog. See more.	Not really This breed is generally not used as a therapy dog. See more.
Therapy Dog Breeds
Detection Dog or Sniffer Dog Which one could be a detection/sniffer dog?	Not really They are not typically employed for this type of work, but there may be exceptional cases.	Yes After proper training, they can excel at this kind of work.	Not really They are not typically employed for this type of work, but there may be exceptional cases.
Search and Rescue Dog (SAR) Which one could be a search and rescue dog?	Not really This dog breed is not typically used as a search and rescue dog.	Not really This dog breed is not typically used as a search and rescue dog.	Not really This dog breed is not typically used as a search and rescue dog.
Boat and Sailor Dog Which one could be a boat dog: McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer?	Not really McNab breed usually doesn't like being on a boat. See more.	Not really Rough Collie breed usually doesn't like being on a boat. See more.	Not really Broholmer breed usually doesn't like being on a boat. See more.
Cart Pulling or Drafting Dog Which one could be a cart pulling or drafting dog?	Not really A drafting dog or draft dog is a dog bred and used for cart pulling. See more.	Not really A drafting dog or draft dog is a dog bred and used for cart pulling. See more.	Yes A drafting dog or draft dog is a dog bred and used for cart pulling. See more.
Fighting Dog / Military Dog	Not really In history, this breed was not really used for combat dog.	Not really In history, this breed was not really used for combat dog.	Not really In history, this breed was not really used for combat dog.

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Reproducibility Comparison

Gestation Length	60-64 days See more.	60-64 days See more.	60-64 days See more.
Litter Frequency	Once a year. More frequent breeding is not healthy. See more.	Once a year. More frequent breeding is not healthy. See more.	Once a year. More frequent breeding is not healthy. See more.
Litter Size How many puppies can McNab and Rough Collie and Broholmer have?	4-6 puppies	4-8 puppies	4-8 puppies
Dog Name Generator – Find A Perfect Name For Your Puppy

McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer Recognition Comparison

AKC Group Which dog is recognized by the AKC?	Not recognized by the American Kennel Club.	Recognized by the American Kennel Club in 1885 as a Herding breed.	Not recognized by the American Kennel Club.
FCI Group Which dog is recognized by the FCI?	Not recognized by FCI.	Recognized by FCI in the Sheepdogs and Cattledogs (except Swiss Cattledogs) group, in the Sheepdogs section.	Recognized by FCI in the Pinscher and Schnauzer - Molossoid and Swiss Mountain and Cattledogs group, in the Molossian type section.
Breed Recognition What other organizations and kennel clubs recognize these dog breeds?	Dog Registry of America Inc.	American Canine Registry American Kennel Club America's Pet Registry Canadian Kennel Club Dog Registry of America Inc. Federation Cynologique Internationale Kennel Club of Great Britain North American Purebred Registry, Inc. American Canine Association, Inc. Australian National Kennel Council Continental Kennel Club National Kennel Club New Zealand Kennel Club United Kennel Club	Dog Registry of America Inc. Federation Cynologique Internationale American Canine Association, Inc. United Kennel Club

Popular Dog Compares

Despite the best intentions, there may be errors. If you find one, please let us know and we will fix it as soon as possible. Contact us here.

Rate This Comparsion - McNab vs Rough Collie vs Broholmer

Reviews